Press "Enter" to skip to content

Op-Ed: Serving up Supreme

Note: Mild Spoilers for “Marty Supreme” ahead 

Marty Mauser races against time to catch a flight to Wembley. This is how he goes about it: the troubling protagonist brandishes a pistol at a former shoe salesman with access to his uncle’s safe. Just 20 minutes into the film, Marty has already overstepped moral boundaries to fuel his aspirations. 

Graphic by Matteo Piccarillo

“Marty Supreme” champions a compelling narrative that simmers with restless tension. The protagonist — based loosely on table tennis prodigy Marty Reisman — has compulsive ambitions that shine through a faithfully gritty rendition of 1950s New York 

His unrelenting spirit, however, tempts him into petty desperation, whether that involves larceny or having an affair with a retired actress. On the blue table, Marty eyes the white ball with a firm grip, calculating every hit with precision. But from the Lower East sidelines, his swings aren’t executed as carefully. 

Timothée Chalamet portrays Marty Mauser with unhinged conviction. He channels an abrasive personality that sparks conflict as he paves his way to the Emerald City, or Japan in his case. However, Mauser’s surroundings clash with his lofty ambitions all too often. Manhattan’s congested infrastructure complements the film’s claustrophobic framework, mirroring the protagonist’s ambiguous circumstances. Chalamet’s character navigates musty alleyways and chaotic roads that render a raw, concrete aesthetic. However, the allure of certainty amidst rising tension drives a grippingly erratic screenplay. His fervent energy matches New York City’s restless streets to remarkable effect. 

Josh Safdie doesn’t rely on A24’s reputation for credibility but rather employs unconventional direction, surpassing the expectations of a predictable storyline. It is one of the many reasons why “Marty Supreme” has elevated itself above a standard viewing experience that leaves very little food for thought. The direction also taps into multiple avenues of mixed-media culture. Newcomers Tyler, the Creator; Kevin O’Leary; and Koto Kawaguchi embrace the manic energy behind their respective roles.  

Mr. Wonderful couldn’t have better rendered himself as Milton Rockwell, a vampiric presence that mirrors O’Leary’s intimidating demeanor. The character literally drains Marty’s self-confidence by manipulating his vulnerability: He must reach Tokyo to compete against his rival Endo, and Rockwell is his only connection to a flight there.

Gwyneth Paltrow even punched above her weight with a fervent performance that parallels the behavior of a compulsive winner (…or loser). Through her character, Kay Stone, Josh Safdie presents a retired actress regaining agency in her career. She dominates the screen with her stoic, albeit emotionally hesitant, persona. Her indecisive nature portrays an internally distraught woman tied to a boorish husband in Mr. Rockwell.  

In the initial encounter between Mauser and Stone, she openly rejects his offer to watch him perform in the semi-finals while still weighing the possibility of attending. The character’s words rarely dictate her thoughts, enabling viewers to critically analyze Kay’s mental strain. Marty insists that they meet, prolonging their conversation over a patchy telephone line. He eventually convinces her to purchase a match ticket and convene in the same suite afterwards. Kay’s decision could be perceived as an act of self-determination. Though, it also conveys her desperation to break routine.    

The film intentionally hinges on its unpredictable direction as Marty encounters setbacks while doubling down on his desire to achieve. Every detour eventually leads to Japan, but the journey merits a more compelling reflection. “Marty Supreme” is a hyperactive odyssey that reinforces the consequences of a fallible protagonist with frantic momentum.  

That said, Marty Mauser’s cunning antics might not be for the faint of heart. Timothee Chalamet’s portrayal of a man motivated by winning above all else makes it difficult to justify his actions. While Marty’s arrogance runs the potential risk of alienating viewers, it gives audiences a reason to root for him. Chalamet’s magnetic ambition ignites the screen in a way that yields a more exhilarating response to his victories. Through hell and back, Marty refuses to stop pursuing his goals. What the character lacks in humility, he compensates through intense skill. As much as the film overwhelms audiences, it will also motivate those passionate enough to achieve greatness at all costs.

The opinions on this page do not necessarily reflect those of The Sandspur or Rollins College. Have any additional tips or opinions? Send us your response. We want to hear your voice.

Comments are closed.